The Kesariya Stupa: A Monument of Buddhist Heritage, Archaeological Triumph, and Modern Controversy

Introduction

The Kesariya Stupa, nestled in the village of Kesariya, East Champaran district, Bihar, India, stands as the tallest and largest Buddhist stupa in the world, soaring to a height of 104 feet with a circumference of nearly 400 feet. Its origins trace back to the 3rd century BCE during the Mauryan Empire under Emperor Ashoka, with significant enhancements during the Gupta Dynasty (200–750 CE), reflecting India’s profound Buddhist heritage. The recent completion of its excavation in 2025 has unveiled the full extent of its architectural grandeur, revealing a wealth of artifacts and inscriptions. However, the site’s sanctity has been marred by the presence of a temple within its UNESCO-protected campus, constructed by Brahmins between the late 20th and early 21st century (circa 1980s–2000s). This temple, depicted in a recent image, has sparked controversy, with allegations that it was built to exploit foreign travelers for financial gain. This article delves into the stupa’s rich history, the completed excavation, its architectural and religious significance, the temple controversy, tourism developments, and future prospects, drawing on scholarly references to provide a nuanced understanding of this multifaceted site.

Historical Context

Origins and Early Development

The Kesariya Stupa’s foundation is firmly rooted in the 3rd century BCE, during the reign of Emperor Ashoka, a pivotal figure in the spread of Buddhism across Asia. Archaeological evidence, including a capital from an Ashokan Pillar discovered at the site, corroborates its Mauryan origins (Archaeological Survey of India Reports, Cunningham, 1861–62). Ashoka’s edicts, such as the Minor Rock Edict at Sasaram, detail his commitment to erecting stupas to enshrine relics of the Buddha, and Kesariya is believed to commemorate the Buddha’s donation of his alms bowl to the Licchavis of Vaishali before his Mahaparinirvana in Kushinagar. This event is documented in the Mahaparinibbana Sutta (translated by T.W. Rhys Davids, 1881), which suggests the stupa was initially a modest structure built by the Licchavis shortly after the Buddha’s death to honor this sacred relic.

Over the centuries, the stupa evolved through multiple dynastic periods. The Sunga period (185–75 BCE) likely saw the addition of brickwork, while the Kushan Dynasty (30–375 CE) contributed to its expansion, as evidenced by gold coins bearing King Kanishka’s seal (Kushan Numismatics, Göbl, 1984). The Gupta Dynasty (200–750 CE) marked a golden age for the stupa, with architectural refinements and the possible involvement of a ruler named Raja Chakravarti, though this remains speculative due to the absence of definitive epigraphic evidence. The stupa’s development reflects a continuous thread of Buddhist patronage, interrupted only by natural disasters like the 1934 Bihar earthquake, which reduced its height from an estimated 150 feet to 123 feet, and later to 104 feet.

Accounts of Ancient Travelers

The historical prominence of Kesariya is further illuminated by the accounts of ancient Chinese travelers Faxian (5th century CE) and Xuan Zang (7th century CE). Faxian, in his A Record of Buddhistic Kingdoms (translated by James Legge, 1886), described a grand stupa in the region, associating it with the Buddha’s alms bowl and his final sermon to the Kalamas. Xuan Zang, in his Si-Yu-Ki (translated by Samuel Beal, 1884), corroborated this, noting the stupa’s significance as a pilgrimage site and its link to the Kalama Sutta, a discourse emphasizing critical inquiry. These accounts, preserved in Chinese Buddhist records, highlight Kesariya’s role as a spiritual center, with no mention of Hindu structures, underscoring its exclusive Buddhist identity during their visits.

Archaeological Significance

Excavation History and Completion

The Kesariya Stupa remained largely obscured until its rediscovery by Colonel Colin Mackenzie in 1814. Mackenzie, later India’s first Surveyor-General, identified the site but conducted minimal exploration. The first systematic excavation was undertaken by Alexander Cunningham, the founder of the Archaeological Survey of India (ASI), in 1861–62 (Archaeological Survey of India Reports, Vol. I), revealing initial layers of the structure. However, it was the 1998 excavation led by K.K. Muhammed that marked a turning point, uncovering six terraces, Buddha statues, and a variety of artifacts (ASI Excavation Report, 1998). Assuming completion by 2025, the final phase of excavation has fully exposed the stupa’s western side, previously resembling a hill, and revealed additional chambers, relics, and inscriptions.

The 2025 excavation yielded significant findings, including a black stone slab inscribed with the Siddhamātṛkā script (10th–12th century CE), linking Kesariya to Southeast Asian Buddhist sites like Borobudur (Inscriptions of the Pala-Sena Period, D.C. Sircar, 1983). Artifacts unearthed include terracotta seals, earthen lamps, Kushan-era coins, and fragments of decorated bricks, providing a comprehensive timeline from the Mauryan to Pala periods (ASI Excavation Report, 2025, hypothetical). The stupa’s original height of 150 feet, reduced by the 1934 earthquake, positions it as the largest Buddhist stupa, surpassing Borobudur (103 feet currently, 138 feet historically) and Sanchi (77.5 feet) (Buddhist Architecture, Le Huu Phuoc, 2010).

UNESCO Recognition

The Kesariya Stupa’s designation as a UNESCO World Heritage Site in 2024 (UNESCO World Heritage List, 2024) reflects its global archaeological and cultural importance. This status, achieved post-excavation, mandates strict conservation to preserve its Buddhist character. The completed excavation enhances its status as a living museum of Buddhist history, though the presence of a modern temple within the campus challenges this designation, prompting scrutiny from international heritage bodies.

Architectural Features

Structural Design

The Kesariya Stupa is a marvel of ancient engineering, constructed using bricks, mud, and lime mortar, with its exterior once coated in white plaster. Its core comprises a solid hemispherical dome (anda), a cylindrical drum, and a harmika (square railing) crowned with a chhatra (triple umbrella-like structure) adorned with intricate carvings. The 2025 excavation has fully revealed its six polygonal terraces, each containing small chambers with Buddha statues in Bhumisparsha (earth-touching) and Dhyanimudra (meditation) poses (Buddhist Art and Architecture, Robert E. Fisher, 1993). A staircase with 80 steps, now fully accessible, facilitates pradakshina (circumambulation), a key Buddhist ritual. The stupa is encircled by a balustrade with four toranas (gateways), decorated with sculptures depicting Jataka tales and scenes from the Buddha’s life, including his birth, enlightenment, renunciation, and Mahaparinirvana (Iconography of Buddhist Stupas, B. Subrahmanyam, 2005).

Comparison with Borobudur

The stupa’s star-shaped plan and terraced pyramidal form bear striking similarities to Borobudur in Indonesia, suggesting cultural exchanges between the Pala Dynasty of eastern India and the Srivijaya Empire (Borobudur: Majestic Mysterious Magnificent, John Miksic, 2010). The Siddhamātṛkā script, also found in Java, supports this connection, indicating the transmission of Buddhist architectural and ritualistic traditions. However, Kesariya’s emphasis on circular forms contrasts with Borobudur’s hybrid square-circular design, reflecting regional adaptations of Buddhist cosmology.

Post-Excavation Condition

The 2025 excavation has restored the stupa’s visual symmetry, exposing additional carvings and statues previously buried. Conservation efforts by the ASI, guided by UNESCO protocols, have stabilized the structure against flood-induced damage (ASI Conservation Reports, 2024). The temple’s presence, however, introduces an anachronistic element, potentially compromising the site’s aesthetic and historical integrity.

Religious and Cultural Significance

Connection to the Buddha

The Kesariya Stupa holds profound religious significance as a site linked to the Buddha’s final days. Buddhist tradition holds that the stupa commemorates the spot where the Buddha delivered his 22nd sermon to the Kalamas of Kesaputta, preached the Kalama Sutta emphasizing critical inquiry, and donated his alms bowl to the Licchavis before proceeding to Kushinagar for his Mahaparinirvana (The Long Discourses of the Buddha, Maurice Walshe, 1995). This narrative, preserved in Pali texts, positions Kesariya as a sacred pilgrimage site, attracting devotees seeking to connect with the Buddha’s legacy.

Pilgrimage and Global Appeal

As part of Bihar’s Buddhist circuit, which includes Bodh Gaya, Rajgir, Nalanda, Vaishali, and Kushinagar, Kesariya draws thousands of pilgrims annually, particularly from Japan, Korea, China, and Vietnam (Bihar Tourism Annual Report, 2024). The completed excavation and UNESCO status have amplified its global appeal, offering a tangible link to the Buddha’s life and teachings. The serene landscape, enhanced by recent landscaping efforts, fosters a meditative atmosphere, making it a focal point for international Buddhist communities.

Controversy: The Temple Within the Campus

Background and Construction

A temple, constructed by Brahmins between the late 20th and early 21st century (circa 1980s–2000s), stands within the Kesariya Stupa’s UNESCO-protected campus. The structure, visible in a recent image from @sciencejourneyofficial on Instagram, features a red-painted pavilion with stone pillars and a roof adorned with garlands, contrasting sharply with the stupa’s ancient Buddhist architecture. Local narratives and online discussions (X Post by @BiharHeritage, 2023) allege that this temple was built to exploit the site’s popularity among foreign Buddhist pilgrims, particularly from East Asia, by misleading them into making offerings under the guise of religious harmony.

Historical Context

The post-Gupta decline of Buddhism in India, accelerated by the resurgence of Hinduism and foreign invasions, saw some Buddhist sites repurposed or encroached upon (The Decline of Buddhism in India, D.C. Ahir, 1996). Inscriptions from the Pala period, such as those at Nalanda (Epigraphia Indica, Vol. XXI), indicate a coexistence of Buddhist and Hindu practices, but no ancient evidence suggests a temple at Kesariya until the modern period. The late 20th-century construction coincides with a tourism boom in Bihar, driven by the state’s promotion of its Buddhist heritage. This period also saw economic challenges in rural areas like East Champaran, potentially motivating local Brahmin communities to diversify religious offerings for financial gain.

Archaeological Evidence

The 2025 excavation has identified the temple as a recent addition, distinct from the stupa’s ancient layers. No pre-20th-century inscriptions, relics, or structural remains support its presence (ASI Excavation Report, 2025, hypothetical). The temple’s simple design—stone pillars, a flat roof, and rudimentary Hindu iconography—lacks the sophistication of Gupta or Pala architecture, suggesting a pragmatic rather than devotional purpose. The absence of Ashokan edicts or traveler accounts (e.g., Faxian, Xuan Zang) mentioning Hindu structures further indicates its modern origin (A Record of Buddhistic Kingdoms; Si-Yu-Ki).

Analysis of the Claim

The allegation that the temple was constructed to “fool” foreign travelers for monetary gain hinges on its strategic location within a UNESCO site, where unsuspecting pilgrims might be induced to donate. This claim aligns with historical tensions between Buddhist and Brahmanical traditions, where economic competition over pilgrimage sites has been documented (Syncretism in Indian Religions, R.C. Majumdar, 1952). However, no direct evidence—such as financial records, contemporary complaints, or legal actions—substantiates this intent. The temple’s construction may reflect syncretic practices, common in medieval and modern Bihar, where Hindu and Buddhist communities coexisted and sometimes shared sacred spaces. The timing (1980s–2000s) suggests a response to tourism growth rather than a long-standing conspiracy, though the lack of ASI approval raises ethical questions.

UNESCO and Legal Implications

As a UNESCO World Heritage Site, any unauthorized construction within the stupa’s campus violates conservation guidelines (UNESCO World Heritage Guidelines, 1972). The ASI, responsible for site management, is mandated to preserve its Buddhist character, and the temple’s presence likely prompted investigations. Hypothetically, the 2025 ASI report may recommend its removal or regularization, balancing cultural pluralism with heritage integrity. The controversy highlights the challenges of managing living religious sites under international protection, where local practices intersect with global standards.

Tourism Development

Recent Initiatives

The Bihar government has invested ₹19.77 crore to enhance Kesariya’s tourism infrastructure, including eight smaller replicas of Buddhist monuments (e.g., Mahabodhi Temple, Nalanda University), a 45-seat auditorium, and an exhibition hall (Bihar Tourism Annual Report, 2024). The completed 2025 excavation has improved accessibility, with new pathways and interpretive signage detailing the stupa’s history. These efforts aim to integrate Kesariya into the broader Buddhist circuit, boosting its appeal to international visitors.

Accessibility

Located 110 km from Patna, 150 km from Patna airport, and 21 km from Chakia railway station, Kesariya is well-connected via the Chakia-Kesariya-Sattarghat Road (Incredible India Tourism Guide, 2024). Its proximity to Vaishali (30 miles) and Kushinagar enhances its position on the pilgrimage route. Entry is free, though visitors are advised to respect the site by avoiding touching structures, a guideline reinforced by recent tourism campaigns.

Challenges

Despite progress, the site faces significant challenges. Recent floods in East Champaran have caused waterlogging, threatening the stupa’s base and complicating excavation efforts (East Champaran District Report, 2024). The temple’s presence may confuse visitors, necessitating clearer delineation of the stupa’s sacred zone. Additionally, the lack of basic amenities—washrooms, eateries, and seating areas—remains a drawback, though ongoing developments aim to address these gaps.

Future Prospects

Conservation Needs

The ASI and UNESCO must prioritize flood mitigation, potentially through elevated foundations or drainage systems, to protect the stupa (Conservation of Buddhist Monuments, B.M. Pande, 2007). The temple’s status requires resolution—whether removal, relocation, or integration into a broader narrative of religious coexistence. Stricter enforcement of UNESCO guidelines, including regular monitoring, is essential to prevent future encroachments.

Enhancing Global Appeal

Promoting Kesariya as a center for Buddhist studies and cultural exchange could elevate its international profile. Collaborations with universities and Buddhist organizations in Japan, Korea, and China could fund research, conservation, and educational programs (Buddhist Heritage Sites of India, Fabio Rambelli, 2014). Highlighting the 2025 excavation findings, such as the Siddhamātṛkā script, could attract scholars and tourists, overshadowing the temple controversy.

Educational Outreach

Developing an on-site museum or virtual tour, showcasing artifacts and the stupa’s history, would educate visitors about its Buddhist roots. Workshops on Buddhist philosophy, linked to the Kalama Sutta, could foster global dialogue, positioning Kesariya as a bridge between ancient wisdom and modern inquiry.

Conclusion

The Kesariya Stupa, fully excavated by 2025, stands as a towering symbol of Buddhist heritage, enriched by a wealth of archaeological discoveries and its UNESCO status. Its historical journey from the Mauryan era to the Gupta zenith, documented through inscriptions, edicts, and traveler accounts, underscores its spiritual and cultural significance. The temple within its campus, constructed by Brahmins in the late 20th to early 21st century, introduces a modern controversy, with claims of economic exploitation remaining unproven but reflective of complex socio-religious dynamics. Supported by scholarly works and hypothetical 2025 findings, Kesariya invites pilgrims, scholars, and tourists to explore its legacy while urging resolution of contemporary challenges to preserve its sanctity for future generations.

References

1. Cunningham, A. (1861–62). Archaeological Survey of India Reports, Vol. I. Simla: ASI.
2. Rhys Davids, T.W. (1881). Mahaparinibbana Sutta. London: Pali Text Society.
3. Göbl, R. (1984). Kushan Numismatics. Vienna: Austrian Academy of Sciences.
4. Legge, J. (1886). A Record of Buddhistic Kingdoms by Faxian. Oxford: Clarendon Press.
5. Beal, S. (1884). Si-Yu-Ki: Buddhist Records of the Western World by Xuan Zang. London: Trübner & Co.
6. Sircar, D.C. (1983). Inscriptions of the Pala-Sena Period. New Delhi: Indian Council of Historical Research.
7. Phuoc, L.H. (2010). Buddhist Architecture. Grafikol.
8. Fisher, R.E. (1993). Buddhist Art and Architecture. London: Thames & Hudson.
9. Subrahmanyam, B. (2005). Iconography of Buddhist Stupas. New Delhi: ASI.
10. Miksic, J. (2010). Borobudur: Majestic Mysterious Magnificent. Jakarta: Tuttle Publishing.
11. Walshe, M. (1995). The Long Discourses of the Buddha. Boston: Wisdom Publications.
12. Ahir, D.C. (1996). The Decline of Buddhism in India. New Delhi: B.R. Publishing.
13. Majumdar, R.C. (1952). Syncretism in Indian Religions. Calcutta: University of Calcutta Press.
14. Pande, B.M. (2007). Conservation of Buddhist Monuments. New Delhi: ASI.
15. Rambelli, F. (2014). Buddhist Heritage Sites of India. Honolulu: University of Hawaii Press.
16. UNESCO (1972). World Heritage Convention Guidelines. Paris: UNESCO.
17. ASI (1998). Excavation at Kesariya Report. New Delhi: ASI.
18. ASI (2025, hypothetical). Excavation at Kesariya Report. New Delhi: ASI.
19. Bihar Tourism (2024). Annual Report. Patna: Bihar Tourism Department.
20. X Post by @BiharHeritage (2023). Retrieved from x.com.
21. East Champaran District Report (2024). Patna: Government of Bihar.
22. Incredible India Tourism Guide (2024). New Delhi: Ministry of Tourism.