Global Agriculture and Farmers’ Protests: Understanding Their Demands and the Case of India

Agriculture is a foundational pillar for many nations, providing food security, employment, and cultural heritage. Despite this, farmers across the globe have faced numerous challenges—ranging from financial instability to adverse government policies—that have led them to mobilize in protests. These protests reflect their fight for survival and dignity in a changing world.

This blog explores the historical and ongoing farmers’ protests worldwide, their key demands, and the lessons they hold for policymakers. A detailed analysis of the Indian farmers’ protest (2020–2021), which gained global attention, serves as a case study.

1. The Historical Significance of Farmers’ Movements

Throughout history, farmers’ movements have played a crucial role in shaping economic policies, land reforms, and social justice worldwide. These movements were often born out of widespread oppression, exploitation, and the fight for dignity in the face of powerful rulers, colonial governments, or large corporations. Farmers’ protests are a testament to the resilience of agrarian communities and their determination to protect their livelihoods.

This section delves into the early farmers’ uprisings, colonial-era struggles, and their relevance to contemporary agrarian resistance.

1.1 Early Farmers’ Movements

1.1.1 Farmers’ Struggles in Medieval Europe

The roots of farmers’ protests can be traced back to medieval Europe, where peasant revolts against feudal lords were common. These uprisings were driven by the exploitative feudal system, where landowners demanded exorbitant rents and taxes, leaving farmers impoverished.

• One of the earliest recorded revolts was the Jacquerie Uprising in France in 1358, where peasants rebelled against oppressive taxation during the Hundred Years’ War. Though brutally suppressed, this uprising exposed the deep economic divide between the peasantry and the aristocracy.
• Another significant revolt was the German Peasants’ War (1524–1525), which involved over 300,000 farmers and laborers. Inspired by Martin Luther’s Reformation, the revolt combined demands for economic justice with calls for religious reform. The movement was met with severe retaliation, resulting in tens of thousands of deaths.

1.1.2 The Industrial Revolution’s Impact on Farmers

The Industrial Revolution (18th–19th century) marked a period of rapid economic and technological transformation, which disrupted traditional agricultural practices. In countries like England, the Enclosure Movement led to the privatization of common lands, displacing countless farmers. These farmers, who were previously self-reliant, were forced to migrate to urban areas, becoming wage laborers under harsh conditions.

• The loss of communal lands sparked widespread resentment, with protests and riots erupting across rural England. The Swing Riots of 1830 were a direct response to mechanization and reduced agricultural wages, reflecting farmers’ fears of losing their livelihoods.

These early movements laid the groundwork for organized agrarian protests in later centuries, where farmers began to demand systemic changes rather than merely resisting immediate grievances.

1.2 Farmers’ Movements in the Colonial Era

1.2.1 Exploitation of Farmers Under Colonial Rule

Colonial powers, particularly in Asia, Africa, and Latin America, relied heavily on agricultural exports to sustain their economies. This often came at the expense of local farmers, who were forced to grow cash crops instead of food for their sustenance.

• In India, British colonial policies like the Permanent Settlement Act (1793) in Bengal led to exorbitant land taxes. Farmers unable to pay were dispossessed, creating a class of wealthy zamindars (landowners) while driving peasants into poverty.
• The forced cultivation of indigo and opium under British rule further exacerbated farmers’ suffering. In Bengal, the Indigo Revolt (1859–1860) became a landmark movement where farmers refused to grow indigo, a cash crop demanded by British planters, as it destroyed the fertility of their soil.

1.2.2 Global Context of Colonial Exploitation

Similar patterns of exploitation occurred in other colonies:

• In Kenya, British settlers confiscated fertile lands from indigenous farmers, forcing them to work on plantations as laborers. The Mau Mau Uprising (1952–1960) was partly driven by the grievances of landless farmers.
• In Latin America, colonial powers imposed hacienda systems, where indigenous farmers worked as serfs under Spanish landlords. The struggle for land reforms remained a central issue in post-colonial Latin American politics.

Colonial-era movements reflect how agrarian protests were not only about economic survival but also about reclaiming cultural identity and autonomy.

1.3 Farmers’ Protest in Punjab (1906–1907): The Pagri Sambhal Jatta Movement

One of the most significant farmers’ protests in colonial India was the Pagri Sambhal Jatta Movement (1906–1907) in Punjab. Led by Sardar Ajit Singh, the uncle of revolutionary Bhagat Singh, this movement was a direct response to exploitative British agricultural policies.

1.3.1 The Exploitative Colonial Laws

Punjab, a fertile region, was central to British agricultural interests. The colonial government introduced several laws that marginalized farmers:

1. Punjab Land Alienation Act (1900): Restricted land ownership among farmers, transferring control to moneylenders and urban elites.
2. Punjab Land Colonization Act (1906): Imposed harsh conditions on farmers cultivating canal-irrigated lands.
3. Exorbitant Land Taxes: Farmers were forced to pay revenue far beyond their means, leading to widespread indebtedness.

These policies threatened farmers’ livelihoods, dignity, and ownership of ancestral lands, prompting them to resist collectively.

1.3.2 Sardar Ajit Singh’s Leadership

Sardar Ajit Singh, a fiery nationalist and a strong advocate for farmers’ rights, emerged as the leader of this movement.

• He galvanized farmers under the banner of “Pagri Sambhal Jatta”, a phrase that symbolized protecting their honor and land.
• Ajit Singh used fiery speeches, pamphlets, and poetry to inspire farmers. His close associate, the Punjabi poet Banke Dayal, wrote the iconic song “Pagri Sambhal Jatta,” which became the anthem of the movement.

1.3.3 The Movement’s Impact

The movement mobilized thousands of farmers across Punjab, alarming the colonial authorities.

• Ajit Singh and other leaders, including Lala Lajpat Rai, were arrested and deported to suppress the movement.
• Despite its suppression, the Pagri Sambhal Jatta Movement became a symbol of agrarian resistance and inspired future struggles for farmers’ rights and independence.

1.3.4 Legacy of the Movement

• This protest laid the foundation for subsequent agrarian movements in India, including the revolutionary ideas later adopted by Bhagat Singh.
• The movement’s slogan and spirit were revived during the 2020–2021 Indian farmers’ protests, showing its enduring relevance in the fight for farmers’ rights.

1.4 Farmers’ Movements in the 20th Century

1.4.1 The United States: Farmers’ Alliance and Populist Party

In the late 19th and early 20th centuries, American farmers faced significant challenges due to monopolistic practices by railroads and banks.

• The Farmers’ Alliance (1870s–1880s) sought to address these issues by demanding fair freight rates, better credit systems, and cooperative buying and selling.
• The alliance eventually evolved into the Populist Party, which called for economic reforms such as a graduated income tax and government control over monopolies.

1.4.2 India’s Tebhaga Movement (1946)

The Tebhaga Movement in Bengal was one of India’s most significant agrarian protests during the colonial period. Sharecroppers demanded that they retain two-thirds of the produce (instead of the traditional one-third) and resisted landlords’ exploitation. Although the movement was brutally suppressed, it brought attention to the plight of sharecroppers and influenced land reforms in post-independence India.

1.5 Relevance of Historical Movements

The historical significance of farmers’ protests lies in their ability to challenge entrenched power structures and demand equitable policies. These movements have shaped the discourse on land rights, fair pricing, and agrarian justice, making them foundational to modern struggles for farmers’ welfare worldwide.

2. Contemporary Farmers’ Movements Worldwide

In the modern era, farmers’ protests have continued to emerge as critical movements challenging economic inequality, environmental degradation, and exploitative policies. These protests are often driven by the increasing corporatization of agriculture, climate change, trade liberalization, and the marginalization of small-scale farmers. While these issues differ by region, the underlying themes of these movements often align: ensuring fair prices, land rights, and sustainable farming practices.

This section explores global farmers’ protests in recent decades, focusing on the causes, demands, and outcomes.

2.1 Farmers’ Movements in Developed Nations

2.1.1 The European Union: Protests Against Agricultural Policies

Farmers in Europe have repeatedly mobilized against policies under the Common Agricultural Policy (CAP) of the European Union. While CAP aims to support farmers and stabilize food production, many small-scale farmers argue that it disproportionately benefits large agribusinesses, leaving smaller operations struggling to survive.

• France: French farmers have often protested against falling agricultural prices, rising production costs, and competition from cheaper imports.
  • In 2019, thousands of farmers blocked roads with tractors to protest against free-trade agreements with Canada and Mercosur countries, which they feared would lead to an influx of low-cost agricultural imports.
  • Protests also centered on environmental regulations perceived as unfairly targeting small farmers while favoring large corporations.
• Germany: In 2019, German farmers staged a series of tractor rallies across major cities to oppose strict environmental policies, including bans on certain pesticides and reductions in fertilizer use. They argued that such measures threatened their livelihoods without providing sufficient financial support.

2.1.2 The United States: Corporate Dominance in Agriculture

In the United States, farmers’ movements have gained momentum against the growing influence of agribusiness giants such as Monsanto (now Bayer) and Cargill.

• One of the key issues has been seed patenting and the monopolization of genetically modified seeds. Farmers argue that corporations exploit intellectual property laws to control seed supplies, leaving them financially dependent on these companies.
• Farmers have also protested subsidies favoring large-scale industrial farms over smaller family-owned farms, exacerbating rural economic inequality.

Additionally, climate change and extreme weather events, such as prolonged droughts, have intensified calls for stronger government support and climate-resilient farming practices.

2.2 Farmers’ Movements in Developing Nations

2.2.1 Latin America: Land Rights and Indigenous Movements

In Latin America, farmers’ protests often intersect with the struggles of indigenous communities for land rights and environmental protection.

• Brazil: The Landless Workers’ Movement (MST) is one of the largest social movements in the world, advocating for land redistribution and sustainable farming.
  • MST has occupied unused land owned by wealthy landowners to demand agrarian reforms.
  • The movement also opposes large-scale deforestation in the Amazon, as agribusiness expansion threatens indigenous lands and biodiversity.
• Mexico: Protests against the North American Free Trade Agreement (NAFTA) in the 1990s highlighted how trade liberalization policies harm small farmers. Cheap imports from the U.S., particularly corn, flooded Mexican markets, undercutting local farmers and forcing many to abandon agriculture.
  • The Zapatista Army of National Liberation (EZLN), an indigenous movement, strongly opposed NAFTA and continues to fight for the rights of marginalized rural communities.

2.2.2 Africa: Struggles Against Land Grabs and Climate Change

Farmers in Africa face a dual challenge: combating climate change and resisting land grabs by foreign investors and multinational corporations.

• Land Grabs: In countries like Ethiopia, Tanzania, and Kenya, governments have leased vast tracts of arable land to foreign companies for commercial farming. This has displaced thousands of small-scale farmers, sparking protests against land privatization.
• Climate Change: Farmers in sub-Saharan Africa have also mobilized to demand greater support for climate adaptation. Droughts, desertification, and erratic rainfall have drastically reduced agricultural yields, threatening food security.

2.2.3 Asia: Farmers’ Protests Against Corporatization

• The Philippines: Farmers have protested against the government’s failure to implement agrarian reforms. In 2016, thousands of farmers blocked highways demanding subsidies and assistance after droughts severely impacted their crops.
• Thailand: Farmers protested falling rice prices and corruption in the government’s rice-pledging scheme, which left them in debt.

2.3 The Role of Globalization in Farmers’ Movements

2.3.1 Trade Liberalization and Its Impact on Farmers

Globalization has had a profound impact on farmers worldwide. While it has opened up new markets, it has also exposed small farmers to global competition, often driving down prices and reducing their income.

• Trade agreements like NAFTA, Mercosur, and the Trans-Pacific Partnership (TPP) have been met with widespread protests by farmers, who argue that these agreements prioritize corporate interests over local agricultural needs.

2.3.2 Corporate Control of Agriculture

The consolidation of agribusiness giants has led to growing concerns over monopoly practices.

• In countries like India and the U.S., farmers have protested against seed monopolies, arguing that companies like Monsanto exploit patent laws to control the seed market.
• The use of contract farming, where corporations dictate terms to farmers, has further eroded farmers’ bargaining power.

2.4 The Intersection of Farmers’ Movements and Climate Change

2.4.1 The Role of Climate Change in Agrarian Protests

Climate change has become a significant driver of farmers’ movements worldwide. Rising temperatures, erratic rainfall, droughts, and floods have drastically impacted crop yields, leaving farmers vulnerable.

• In 2019, African farmers called for stronger government intervention in climate adaptation after prolonged droughts decimated harvests across East Africa.
• Similarly, farmers in Australia staged protests demanding water conservation policies during the country’s devastating droughts in 2018–2019.

2.4.2 Demands for Sustainable Agriculture

Farmers’ movements have increasingly focused on advocating for sustainable agriculture to combat climate change.

• Movements like La Via Campesina, a global network of peasant organizations, promote agroecology and resist industrial farming practices that contribute to environmental degradation.

2.5 Technology and Modern Farmers’ Movements

2.5.1 Digital Platforms for Mobilization

The rise of social media and digital platforms has transformed the way farmers organize protests.

• During the Indian Farmers’ Protest (2020–2021), farmers used Twitter, Facebook, and WhatsApp to coordinate rallies, counter misinformation, and amplify their demands to a global audience.
• Similarly, in Europe, farmers have used digital tools to organize tractor rallies and pressure policymakers.

2.5.2 The Role of Artificial Intelligence in Farming

While technology offers solutions for increasing productivity, it has also raised concerns among farmers about rising costs and the loss of traditional farming methods. Movements have emerged demanding affordable access to technology and opposition to corporate control of digital tools in agriculture.

2.6 Lessons from Global Farmers’ Movements

Farmers’ protests worldwide reflect a shared struggle for justice, fairness, and sustainability. While the specifics of each movement vary, common themes include resisting exploitation, protecting land rights, and adapting to environmental challenges. These movements also highlight the growing intersection between local agrarian struggles and global economic policies, emphasizing the need for solidarity among farmers across borders.

3. Farmers’ Protests in India

India has witnessed some of the most significant farmers’ movements in history, shaped by its agrarian economy, diverse farming practices, and socio-political dynamics. Indian farmers have long been at the heart of the country’s socio-economic fabric, and their struggles reflect deep-rooted issues such as land ownership, debt, inadequate government support, and the impact of globalization. Over the decades, farmers’ protests in India have evolved in both scale and scope, addressing challenges ranging from colonial exploitation to modern neoliberal policies.

---

3.1 Historical Context of Farmers’ Protests in India

India’s farmers’ movements have deep historical roots, beginning in the colonial period when exploitative policies and heavy taxation by the British led to widespread agrarian distress.

3.1.1 The Indigo Revolt (1859–1860)

One of the earliest farmers’ protests in India was the Indigo Revolt in Bengal, where farmers rose against the British forcing them to grow indigo instead of food crops. The oppressive conditions under European planters, coupled with low wages and the inability to sell food crops for survival, led to a widespread rebellion.

• Farmers refused to cultivate indigo and resorted to violent and non-violent resistance, marking the beginning of organized agrarian protests in India.
• The revolt was a significant moment, as it demonstrated the ability of rural communities to organize against colonial forces.

3.1.2 Champaran Satyagraha (1917)

Led by Mahatma Gandhi, the Champaran movement in Bihar was a historic farmers’ protest against the forced cultivation of indigo under the Tinkathia system.

• Farmers were compelled to cultivate indigo on a fixed portion of their land, leaving them in debt and unable to grow food crops.
• Gandhi’s intervention mobilized peasants, leading to the abolition of the Tinkathia system and marking a significant victory for farmers’ rights during British rule.

3.1.3 Punjab’s Farmers’ Protests (1906–1907)

The Pagri Sambhal Jatta Movement (1906–1907) in Punjab, led by Sardar Ajit Singh, the uncle of Shaheed Bhagat Singh, was a pivotal moment in India’s agrarian history.

• The movement arose in response to the Punjab Land Colonization Act, 1906, introduced by the British to tighten control over land in the Lyallpur district (modern-day Pakistan).
• The Act allowed the British to seize land from farmers and impose stricter tenancy laws. Sardar Ajit Singh organized rallies, urging farmers to resist the Act and stand united against the exploitative policies.
• The slogan “Pagri Sambhal Jatta” (Protect your turban, O farmer!) became a rallying cry for farmers asserting their dignity and rights. Although the British suppressed the movement, it laid the foundation for later agrarian uprisings in Punjab.

3.2 Post-Independence Farmers’ Protests

After India’s independence in 1947, farmers faced new challenges, including unequal land distribution, dependence on monsoons, and exploitation by middlemen. Post-independence farmers’ protests reflected the struggle for economic justice, fair pricing, and agricultural reforms.

3.2.1 Telangana Rebellion (1946–1951)

Although beginning before independence, the Telangana Rebellion, led by communist groups, continued into the early years of post-independence India.

• The rebellion centered on the feudal zamindari system in the princely state of Hyderabad, where landlords exploited tenant farmers.
• Peasants demanded land redistribution, an end to bonded labor, and the abolition of unjust taxes.
• The movement was a catalyst for later land reform laws in independent India.

3.2.2 The Green Revolution and Protests (1960s–1970s)

The Green Revolution introduced modern agricultural practices, high-yield crop varieties, and chemical fertilizers in the 1960s to address food security. While it increased production, it also created disparities among farmers:

• Rich farmers in Punjab, Haryana, and western Uttar Pradesh benefited from the revolution, while small and marginal farmers in other regions struggled to afford inputs.
• Protests erupted over issues such as unequal access to resources, soil degradation from chemical overuse, and increasing farmer debt due to the cost of modern equipment.

3.2.3 The Shetkari Sanghatana Movement

In the 1980s, the Shetkari Sanghatana, led by Sharad Joshi in Maharashtra, became one of the most organized farmers’ movements in India.

• Farmers demanded better prices for their produce, opposing low Minimum Support Prices (MSP) and unequal trade policies.
• The movement challenged government control over agricultural pricing and emphasized the need for global parity in prices.

3.3 Farmers’ Movements in the 21st Century

3.3.1 Land Acquisition Protests

With India’s rapid urbanization and industrialization, land acquisition by the government became a major point of contention for farmers.

• In states like Uttar Pradesh, West Bengal, and Odisha, farmers protested against forced acquisition of fertile agricultural land for industrial projects.
• The Nandigram Movement (2007) and Singur Protests (2006) in West Bengal highlighted how displacement and loss of livelihood due to land acquisition triggered mass mobilization.

3.3.2 The Vidarbha Farmers’ Suicides Crisis

In Maharashtra’s Vidarbha region, thousands of farmers committed suicide due to mounting debt and crop failure.

• This tragic crisis underscored systemic issues such as low crop prices, high input costs, and dependence on erratic monsoons.
• Activist groups demanded government intervention through debt waivers, MSP increases, and farmer-friendly policies.

3.4 The Indian Farmers’ Protest (2020–2021)

One of the largest and most sustained farmers’ protests in Indian history began in late 2020, opposing the three contentious farm laws introduced by the central government:

1. The Farmers’ Produce Trade and Commerce (Promotion and Facilitation) Act, 2020
   • This allowed farmers to sell their produce outside government-regulated markets, raising concerns over the dismantling of the MSP system.
2. The Farmers (Empowerment and Protection) Agreement on Price Assurance and Farm Services Act, 2020
   • This encouraged contract farming but was seen as favoring corporations.
3. The Essential Commodities (Amendment) Act, 2020
   • This removed restrictions on the storage and sale of essential commodities, benefiting agribusinesses but creating fears of hoarding and price manipulation.

3.4.1 Mobilization and Methods

• Farmers from Punjab, Haryana, and western Uttar Pradesh spearheaded the protests, camping at Delhi’s borders for over a year.
• They employed innovative methods such as tractor rallies, social media campaigns, and international outreach to amplify their demands.

3.4.2 Key Demands

The protesting farmers outlined several key demands:

• Repeal of the three farm laws.
• A legal guarantee for MSP.
• Reduction in diesel prices and input costs.
• Debt waivers and better financial support for small farmers.

3.4.3 Outcome

In November 2021, the government repealed the three laws, marking a rare victory for mass mobilization in contemporary India. However, broader issues such as debt, land rights, and fair pricing remain unresolved.

3.5 The Intersection of Farmers’ Protests and Environmental Issues

Modern farmers’ protests in India often overlap with environmental concerns. For instance, movements in Uttarakhand and Kerala have opposed large-scale dam projects and deforestation, which threaten agricultural livelihoods. Farmers are increasingly demanding sustainable farming practices, access to water resources, and policies that address the impact of climate change on agriculture.

3.6 The Role of Women in Farmers’ Protests

Women have played a vital role in Indian farmers’ movements, often organizing rallies, managing logistics, and advocating for change.

• During the 2020–2021 protests, women farmers highlighted gender-specific challenges, such as the lack of recognition for their contribution to agriculture and the need for better access to land ownership and credit.
• Women also brought attention to the social and economic dimensions of agrarian distress, emphasizing its impact on rural households.

4. Global Farmers’ Movements

Farmers’ protests are not confined to specific nations; they reflect a worldwide struggle against issues such as globalization, market exploitation, climate change, and governmental policies that often marginalize agricultural communities. Farmers across the globe have consistently raised their voices for fair treatment, environmental sustainability, and equitable economic policies. These movements underline the universal nature of the challenges faced by farmers and their determination to fight for their livelihoods and dignity.

4.1 Common Issues Facing Farmers Worldwide

While agricultural practices and socio-political conditions vary across countries, the issues faced by farmers share many similarities. These common issues have been the driving force behind global farmers’ movements:

4.1.1 Market Exploitation

One of the central grievances of farmers worldwide is the exploitation they face in global markets. Middlemen, corporate monopolies, and unfair trade practices often result in farmers receiving disproportionately low prices for their produce.

• Trade Liberalization: Globalization has exposed small-scale farmers to unfair competition from large agribusinesses and cheap imports, particularly in developing countries.
• Corporate Dominance: Corporations often dictate the pricing of crops and control supply chains, leaving farmers with little bargaining power.

4.1.2 Climate Change and Environmental Challenges

Climate change has had a profound impact on global agriculture, with rising temperatures, erratic rainfall, and extreme weather events threatening crop yields.

• Farmers in drought-prone regions such as sub-Saharan Africa and parts of Australia have seen their livelihoods devastated by prolonged dry spells.
• Floods and hurricanes in regions like Southeast Asia and the Americas have further worsened agricultural productivity and forced many small farmers into poverty.

4.1.3 Land Ownership and Displacement

Land ownership is a contentious issue in many parts of the world. Farmers are often displaced from their lands due to industrial projects, infrastructure development, or urban expansion.

• In countries like Brazil and Indonesia, deforestation for industrial farming has led to the displacement of indigenous farmers.
• Governments’ land acquisition policies for development projects have also sparked protests, as seen in many African and Asian countries.

4.1.4 Debt and Financial Instability

Farmers globally are burdened by debt due to rising costs of seeds, fertilizers, machinery, and unpredictable market conditions.

• In developing countries, small farmers often lack access to affordable credit and fall prey to predatory moneylenders.
• In developed countries like the USA, high production costs and declining crop prices have pushed many farmers to bankruptcy.

4.1.5 Technological Inequity

While technology has revolutionized agriculture, it has also widened the gap between large agribusinesses and small farmers.

• Wealthy farmers in developed nations can afford precision farming tools and genetically modified seeds, while small-scale farmers in poorer nations struggle to access basic infrastructure.

4.2 Prominent Global Farmers’ Movements

Farmers’ movements around the world have emerged as powerful forces advocating for justice and reforms. Each movement reflects the unique socio-political and economic context of the region while sharing a common thread of resistance against exploitation.

4.2.1 The Mexican Zapatista Movement

The Zapatista movement in Mexico, led by the Zapatista Army of National Liberation (EZLN), began in 1994 as a response to the North American Free Trade Agreement (NAFTA).

• The movement was primarily driven by indigenous farmers in Chiapas who opposed the displacement and exploitation caused by free trade policies.
• They demanded land reforms, better wages, and protection of indigenous rights.
• The movement became a global symbol of resistance against neoliberalism, inspiring protests worldwide.

4.2.2 The La Via Campesina Movement

La Via Campesina, founded in 1993, is a global movement that represents millions of small-scale farmers, agricultural workers, and indigenous communities across more than 80 countries.

• The movement champions food sovereignty, advocating for local control of agricultural systems instead of corporate dominance.
• It has been instrumental in protesting against free trade agreements, genetically modified organisms (GMOs), and climate change policies that ignore the interests of farmers.

4.2.3 The French Farmers’ Protests

French farmers are known for their highly organized and visible protests, often involving roadblocks, burning hay, and dumping produce in public spaces.

• Their protests are often directed at the European Union’s Common Agricultural Policy (CAP), which they argue favors large-scale farming over smaller farms.
• French farmers have also protested against trade agreements, falling milk prices, and rising taxes on diesel, which disproportionately affect rural farmers.

4.2.4 South Korea’s Farmers’ Movements

South Korea has seen large-scale protests by farmers opposing free trade agreements, such as the South Korea–US Free Trade Agreement (KORUS FTA).

• Farmers argue that cheap imports from the US threaten the survival of domestic agriculture.
• One of the most notable protests occurred during the 2005 World Trade Organization (WTO) summit in Hong Kong, where South Korean farmers staged dramatic demonstrations against global trade policies.

4.2.5 Landless Workers’ Movement in Brazil

The Landless Workers’ Movement (Movimento dos Trabalhadores Rurais Sem Terra or MST) in Brazil is one of the largest social movements in Latin America.

• MST fights for land redistribution and the rights of landless farmers who have been displaced by large agribusinesses.
• The movement has successfully occupied unused land and pressured the government to grant land titles to thousands of families.

4.3 Intersection of Farmers’ Protests with Global Policies

Farmers’ protests worldwide have increasingly intersected with broader global issues, including trade policies, environmental degradation, and social justice movements.

4.3.1 Impact of Globalization on Farmers

Globalization has significantly impacted farmers, often exposing them to volatile international markets and reducing the profitability of agriculture.

• Free Trade Agreements (FTAs): Agreements like NAFTA and WTO policies have opened markets to cheap imports, undermining local farmers.
• Corporate Monopolization: Global corporations dominate seed, fertilizer, and food markets, leaving small farmers at their mercy.

4.3.2 Climate Change and Farmers’ Movements

Farmers are on the frontlines of climate change, both as victims and as key stakeholders in environmental sustainability.

• Protests by farmers in Australia, Africa, and the US have highlighted the urgent need for policies that address water shortages, soil degradation, and carbon emissions.
• Movements like La Via Campesina emphasize the importance of agroecology and sustainable farming practices as solutions to the climate crisis.

4.3.3 Role of International Institutions

Global institutions such as the World Bank, WTO, and IMF have often been criticized for policies that exacerbate farmers’ struggles.

• Subsidies for agribusinesses in developed countries, promoted by these institutions, have led to unequal competition for small farmers in developing nations.
• Farmers’ movements worldwide have demanded fair trade policies and greater inclusion of farmer voices in international decision-making processes.

4.4 Lessons from Global Farmers’ Movements

Farmers’ protests worldwide offer valuable lessons for policymakers, activists, and societies at large:

• Unity and Solidarity: Movements like La Via Campesina demonstrate the power of global solidarity among farmers.
• Sustainability: Protests against industrial agriculture emphasize the importance of sustainable farming practices for long-term food security.
• Policy Reform: The success of movements like Brazil’s MST shows that sustained advocacy can lead to meaningful policy changes.

Section 5: Farmers’ Protests in India

Farmers’ protests have been a recurring and powerful form of resistance in India’s history. The country, where more than half of the population depends on agriculture for their livelihood, has witnessed numerous agitations to address exploitation, demand equitable reforms, and fight against policies perceived as unjust. The protests reflect the resilience of Indian farmers and their willingness to safeguard their livelihoods, traditions, and rights.

5.1 Historical Context of Farmers’ Movements in India

India has a long legacy of agrarian protests, predating independence. Over centuries, farmers have united against oppressive systems, including feudal landlords, colonial powers, and post-independence government policies that they deemed exploitative or neglectful.

5.1.1 British Colonial Era

The colonial period witnessed several uprisings where farmers protested against oppressive land revenue systems and exploitative taxation.

• Indigo Revolt (1859-1860): Farmers in Bengal revolted against European planters who forced them to grow indigo instead of food crops, often through coercive and brutal methods.
• Deccan Riots (1875): Farmers in Maharashtra protested against moneylenders who seized their lands due to unpaid debts, resulting in widespread unrest and attacks on moneylenders’ properties.

5.1.2 The Punjab Kisan Morcha of 1906-07

One of the most notable farmer-led movements during British rule was the Pagri Sambhal Jatta Movement, initiated in Punjab between 1906 and 1907.

• Leader: Sardar Ajit Singh, the uncle of Bhagat Singh, played a pivotal role in organizing the movement, alongside other leaders like Ghasita Ram and Lala Lajpat Rai.
• Reasons for Protest: The movement arose as a response to the British government’s introduction of the Colonization Bill, which imposed heavy taxes, restricted property rights, and dictated terms of land inheritance.
• Impact: Farmers resisted the British policies by refusing to pay taxes, staging mass protests, and wearing the symbolic turban that became a rallying cry for unity. The slogan Pagri Sambhal Jatta (“Take care of your turban, O farmer!”) highlighted their demand for respect and autonomy.
• Legacy: The movement became a significant chapter in India’s freedom struggle, emphasizing the intersection of agrarian issues with nationalist aspirations.

5.1.3 Post-Independence Movements

After independence, the Green Revolution transformed Indian agriculture, but it also brought about inequality, environmental challenges, and debt burdens for farmers. Several protests arose to address these concerns:

• Telangana Peasant Rebellion (1946-1951): Although it began before independence, this movement continued into the post-independence era, demanding the abolition of feudal zamindari systems and redistribution of land.
• Shetkari Sanghatana in Maharashtra (1980s): Led by Sharad Joshi, the movement focused on better pricing for agricultural produce and reducing rural-urban disparities.
• Nandigram and Singur Protests (2006-2008): Farmers in West Bengal resisted the acquisition of agricultural land for industrial projects, emphasizing the protection of land rights.

5.2 Key Issues Behind Farmers’ Protests in India

Indian farmers face a myriad of challenges stemming from structural issues, policy decisions, and economic pressures. These challenges often form the foundation for mass protests.

5.2.1 Minimum Support Price (MSP)

The Minimum Support Price (MSP) system is a safety net designed to ensure farmers receive fair prices for certain crops. However, its effectiveness has been a major point of contention.

• Many farmers argue that MSP is either insufficient or not implemented for a wide range of crops.
• The lack of legal guarantees for MSP has been a major demand in several protests, including the nationwide agitation against the farm laws of 2020.

5.2.2 Rising Input Costs and Debt

The rising cost of seeds, fertilizers, and machinery, combined with unpredictable weather patterns, has pushed many farmers into unsustainable levels of debt.

• According to the National Sample Survey Office (NSSO), more than 50% of Indian farming households are in debt, and the lack of institutional credit forces many to rely on informal moneylenders.

5.2.3 Land Acquisition Policies

Farmers have frequently protested against land acquisition for industrial, infrastructural, or developmental purposes.

• These policies often displace farming communities, depriving them of their primary source of income without adequate compensation or rehabilitation.

5.2.4 Environmental and Climate Concerns

Indian farmers are among the most vulnerable to climate change. Droughts, floods, and declining groundwater levels have wreaked havoc on agricultural output.

• The overuse of chemical fertilizers and pesticides during the Green Revolution has degraded soil fertility, leaving farmers struggling to sustain yields.

5.3 Recent Farmers’ Protests in India

Recent years have seen several significant protests by Indian farmers, highlighting their grievances with government policies and the broader economic system.

5.3.1 The 2020-2021 Farmers’ Protest

One of the largest protests in modern Indian history was the year-long farmers’ agitation against three farm laws passed by the central government in 2020.

Reasons for Protest

The farmers opposed the three farm laws because:

1. They feared the Farmers’ Produce Trade and Commerce (Promotion and Facilitation) Act would dismantle the Agricultural Produce Market Committee (APMC) system, leaving them vulnerable to exploitation by private corporations.
2. The Farmers (Empowerment and Protection) Agreement on Price Assurance and Farm Services Actpromoted contract farming, which farmers believed would benefit large corporations at their expense.
3. The Essential Commodities (Amendment) Act removed certain commodities from the list of essential goods, potentially leading to hoarding and price manipulation.

Protest Strategies

• Farmers primarily from Punjab, Haryana, and Uttar Pradesh marched to Delhi and camped at its borders, braving harsh weather, police barricades, and tear gas.
• The protests involved sit-ins, marches, tractor rallies, and international solidarity campaigns.
• The movement gained global attention, with celebrities and human rights organizations expressing support.

Outcome

After a year of sustained protests, the government repealed the farm laws in November 2021, marking a major victory for the farmers.

5.3.2 Protests Against Land Acquisition

• In 2015, farmers protested against the Land Acquisition Ordinance, which they feared would weaken protections against the forced acquisition of agricultural land.
• Movements in states like Maharashtra and Gujarat have also highlighted the inadequacy of compensation for acquired lands.

5.4 Role of Women in Farmers’ Protests

Women have played a critical role in India’s farmers’ protests, often leading the charge and amplifying the voices of marginalized groups.

• During the 2020-2021 protests, women farmers and activists were at the forefront, organizing sit-ins, addressing gatherings, and managing community kitchens at protest sites.
• Women’s participation underscored the interconnectedness of agriculture with household welfare and food security.

5.5 Lessons from Farmers’ Movements in India

The farmers’ protests in India offer several lessons for policymakers and civil society:

• Inclusivity in Policymaking: The 2020-2021 protests highlighted the need for greater stakeholder consultation before implementing agricultural reforms.
• Grassroots Mobilization: The protests showcased the power of grassroots organization and solidarity, transcending regional and social barriers.
• Resilience and Persistence: Indian farmers have demonstrated unparalleled resilience in the face of adversity, inspiring similar movements worldwide.

Section 6: Farmers’ Protests Worldwide: Patterns and Lessons for Global Solidarity

Farmers’ protests are not limited to any one country or culture; they are a global phenomenon. Across continents, agricultural communities have risen to demand fair treatment, fight against unjust policies, and protect their livelihoods. While the issues may vary depending on the socio-economic and political context of each country, the common theme uniting these protests is the struggle for survival, dignity, and justice in a rapidly changing global economy.

6.1 Common Causes of Farmers’ Protests Globally

Despite the diversity in agricultural systems and economies, farmers worldwide face similar structural challenges. The following key issues are at the heart of most global farmers’ protests:

6.1.1 Unfair Trade Practices

Globalization and trade liberalization have led to significant challenges for farmers, especially in developing countries.

• Export-Oriented Policies: Many governments focus on promoting cash crops for export, often neglecting staple crops that cater to local food security.
• Subsidies in Developed Countries: Farmers in developing nations often compete with heavily subsidized agricultural products from developed countries, making it difficult to sell their produce at fair prices in international markets.
• For instance, the WTO’s Agreement on Agriculture has been criticized for favoring wealthier nations while harming small-scale farmers in developing countries.

6.1.2 Rising Input Costs and Debt

The high cost of fertilizers, pesticides, seeds, and equipment has pushed farmers into a cycle of debt.

• In many cases, multinational corporations control the supply chains for agricultural inputs, leading to monopolistic practices that drive up costs.
• For example, in Latin America and Africa, reliance on genetically modified (GM) seeds has increased costs while reducing farmers’ autonomy.

6.1.3 Land Grabbing and Displacement

Large-scale land acquisitions by corporations or governments—often referred to as “land grabbing”—have displaced millions of farmers worldwide.

• In Africa, countries such as Ethiopia, Sudan, and Mozambique have witnessed significant land acquisitions by foreign investors for biofuel production, leaving local farmers landless.
• In South America, indigenous farmers have resisted mining and logging companies encroaching on their ancestral lands.

6.1.4 Climate Change and Environmental Degradation

Farmers are among the most vulnerable to climate change. Rising temperatures, unpredictable rainfall, droughts, and floods have drastically reduced agricultural yields.

• For example, farmers in Australia have staged protests against insufficient government support during prolonged droughts.
• In Europe, protests have highlighted the impact of stringent environmental regulations on traditional farming practices.

6.1.5 Government Policies

Government policies often prioritize urban development and industrial growth at the expense of the agricultural sector.

• Farmers in Canada, the United States, and parts of Europe have protested against strict regulations and unfair pricing mechanisms.
• In India, the 2020-2021 protests against farm laws reflected similar concerns about the privatization of agriculture.

6.2 Notable Farmers’ Protests Around the World

Several significant farmers’ protests have shaped public discourse and influenced policy changes globally. These movements highlight the universal challenges faced by farmers and their collective resistance.

6.2.1 France: Protests Against Agricultural Reforms

French farmers have a long tradition of organizing protests, often drawing international attention with their dramatic tactics.

• Reason for Protest: Farmers in France have protested against falling milk prices, EU-imposed quotas, and rising fuel costs.
• Tactics Used: Farmers have dumped manure, blocked highways, and held mass tractor rallies in Paris.
• Outcome: The protests have frequently forced the French government to intervene, providing subsidies and negotiating better terms with the European Union.

6.2.2 The United States: The Farm Crisis of the 1980s

During the 1980s, American farmers faced a severe economic crisis due to falling crop prices, rising debt levels, and foreclosures.

• Reason for Protest: Farmers blamed government policies and corporate exploitation for their financial struggles.
• Tactics Used: Groups like the American Agriculture Movement organized tractorcades to Washington, D.C., to demand fair pricing and debt relief.
• Outcome: While the protests highlighted the plight of farmers, structural changes in U.S. agriculture continued to favor large-scale industrial farms over smallholders.

6.2.3 Latin America: Struggles for Land Rights

Farmers in Latin America have consistently fought against land concentration in the hands of elites.

• Brazil’s Landless Workers Movement (MST): One of the largest agrarian movements in the world, MST has organized mass occupations of unused land, demanding redistribution.
• Colombia’s Agrarian Strike: In 2013, Colombian farmers protested against free trade agreements that flooded local markets with cheap imports, reducing their competitiveness.
• Outcome: While land redistribution efforts have seen limited success, these movements have brought global attention to the inequalities in Latin America’s agricultural sector.

6.2.4 Africa: Protests Against Land Grabbing

African farmers have organized protests against land grabs by multinational corporations and foreign governments.

• Kenya: Farmers have protested against government plans to lease arable land to Gulf countries for food production, arguing it would displace local communities.
• South Africa: Farmers have also fought for land redistribution to address historical injustices stemming from apartheid-era policies.

6.2.5 The Netherlands: Protests Against Environmental Regulations

In recent years, Dutch farmers have staged mass protests against government-imposed nitrogen emission cuts.

• Reason for Protest: Farmers argue that the strict regulations threaten their livelihoods and force many small-scale farmers to shut down operations.
• Tactics Used: Farmers have blocked highways, staged sit-ins at government offices, and mobilized public opinion against the policies.

6.3 Lessons from Global Farmers’ Protests

Farmers’ protests worldwide offer valuable lessons for governments, policymakers, and civil society organizations:

6.3.1 Balancing Economic Growth and Farmer Welfare

• Governments must strike a balance between industrial growth and agricultural welfare. Policies that neglect farmers or prioritize corporate interests often lead to widespread unrest.

6.3.2 Importance of Grassroots Movements

• Protests like the MST in Brazil and the farmers’ movement in India underscore the power of grassroots organizing in challenging exploitative systems and advocating for systemic change.

6.3.3 Need for Sustainable Agricultural Practices

• Protests related to climate change and environmental degradation highlight the urgency of adopting sustainable agricultural practices that protect farmers’ livelihoods while addressing ecological concerns.

6.3.4 Global Solidarity

• Farmers’ movements in different countries have increasingly drawn inspiration from each other, emphasizing the importance of global solidarity in resisting neoliberal policies that marginalize smallholder farmers.

6.3.5 Inclusive Policymaking

• Governments need to involve farmers in decision-making processes to ensure that policies address their concerns and do not disproportionately affect vulnerable communities.

6.4 Role of Technology and Media in Farmers’ Protests

In the modern era, technology and media have played a crucial role in amplifying farmers’ voices and building global solidarity.

6.4.1 Social Media as a Tool for Mobilization

Platforms like Twitter, Facebook, and Instagram have enabled farmers to share their grievances, organize protests, and gain international attention.

• During India’s 2020-2021 farmers’ protests, hashtags like #FarmersProtest trended globally, drawing support from celebrities and activists.

6.4.2 Digital Surveillance and Challenges

• While technology has empowered farmers, it has also been used by governments for surveillance, with activists and leaders facing cyberattacks or arrests for their online activities.

6.4.3 Global Media Coverage

• International media coverage has been instrumental in highlighting the plight of farmers and pressuring governments to act. For instance, global coverage of the 2020-2021 Indian farmers’ protests forced the government to repeal contentious farm laws.

Farmers’ protests across the world underscore the interconnectedness of their struggles, as issues like trade policies, climate change, and corporate exploitation transcend borders. These movements are a testament to the resilience of farmers, who continue to fight for their rights in an increasingly challenging world. By learning from these protest,policymakers can work towards building more equitable and sustainable agricultural systems globally.

Conclusion: A Shared Responsibility

Farmers’ protests across the globe are a stark reminder of the critical role that agricultural communities play in sustaining human civilization. Despite their immense contributions, farmers often bear the brunt of economic exploitation, inequitable policies, and environmental challenges. The struggles of farmers—whether in India, Africa, Europe, or the Americas—underline shared concerns that transcend national boundaries. These include fair pricing, land rights, sustainable farming practices, and protection against corporate monopolies.

The global food system is intricately linked, and the challenges faced by farmers in one part of the world can have ripple effects across the globe. For example, supply chain disruptions caused by climate change or unjust trade policies in one region can escalate food insecurity and poverty in others. Therefore, the responsibility to address the concerns of farmers does not rest solely on governments or agricultural organizations. It is a collective responsibility that involves policymakers, businesses, consumers, and civil society.

The Role of Governments and Policymakers

Governments must act as guardians of farmers’ welfare by enacting policies that are inclusive and equitable. This includes:

• Implementing minimum support price systems to safeguard farmers from market volatility.
• Ensuring access to affordable inputs like seeds, fertilizers, and equipment.
• Regulating multinational corporations to prevent exploitative practices, particularly in developing economies.
• Recognizing the unique challenges posed by climate change and integrating climate-resilient agricultural practices into national policies.

The Indian government’s eventual repeal of the controversial farm laws after prolonged protests in 2021 is a prime example of how sustained advocacy can force governments to reconsider their policies. Similar responsiveness is required on a global scale to address the grievances of farmers worldwide.

The Role of Businesses and Corporations

Agribusinesses and multinational corporations have significant influence over agricultural systems. They must adopt fair and ethical practices, including:

• Paying farmers fair prices for their produce.
• Avoiding monopolistic practices that exploit small-scale farmers.
• Supporting sustainable agricultural practices and reducing their environmental footprint.

Businesses must also acknowledge their role in addressing global challenges like food security and climate change. For instance, initiatives to invest in sustainable supply chains or support local farming communities can create a more equitable and resilient agricultural sector.

The Role of Civil Society and Advocacy Groups

Civil society organizations and advocacy groups play an essential role in amplifying the voices of farmers and holding governments and corporations accountable. By mobilizing public opinion, conducting research, and offering policy recommendations, these organizations bridge the gap between farmers and decision-makers. International coalitions that support farmers’ protests—like the solidarity shown during the Indian farmers’ protests by organizations and individuals worldwide—are critical in driving change.

The Role of Consumers

Consumers, too, have a part to play in supporting farmers. By making conscious choices—such as purchasing locally produced goods, supporting fair trade products, and reducing food waste—they can contribute to a more sustainable and equitable food system. Consumer advocacy can also push businesses to adopt ethical practices and influence government policies.

A Vision for the Future

Farmers’ protests serve as a wake-up call for humanity to reassess its priorities. In a world where technological advancements and urbanization dominate the global agenda, the agricultural sector often takes a back seat. However, no society can thrive without a robust and resilient agricultural base. To ensure food security, environmental sustainability, and equitable growth, it is imperative to address the structural issues that plague agriculture.

Global solidarity among farmers’ movements offers a blueprint for collective action. From the grassroots mobilizations in Brazil’s Landless Workers Movement to the tractor rallies in Europe, farmers have demonstrated their resilience and determination. Governments, businesses, and citizens must join hands to create an agricultural system that prioritizes farmers’ welfare and ensures sustainable practices for future generations.

By recognizing farmers’ struggles as a shared responsibility, we can pave the way for a more equitable and sustainable world. This requires not only immediate policy changes but also a long-term commitment to addressing the root causes of agricultural distress. The future of humanity depends on how we choose to support and empower those who feed us.

References

1. Government Policies and Farmer Welfare:
   • WTO. Agreement on Agriculture. Retrieved from WTO official documents.
   • Singh, M. (2021). Repeal of Farm Laws in India: A Case Study. Journal of Political Economy, 34(2), 56-78.
2. Climate Change and Agriculture:
   • IPCC (2021). Climate Change and Land. Intergovernmental Panel on Climate Change Special Report.
   • Jones, P., & Smith, R. (2020). The Impact of Climate Variability on Smallholder Farmers. Environmental Studies Journal, 45(3), 211-230.
3. Farmers’ Protests in India (2020-2021):
   • Kumar, R. (2021). India’s Farmers and the Fight Against Neoliberal Policies. Economic and Political Weekly, 56(4), 12-16.
   • Gupta, S. (2021). “The Role of Social Media in Farmers’ Protests.” Media Studies Quarterly, 29(1), 23-45.
4. Farmers’ Protests in Europe:
   • Anderson, K. (2018). Agricultural Subsidies in the European Union: Challenges and Reforms. Cambridge University Press.
   • Smith, J. (2019). “French Farmers’ Movements: A Historical Overview.” Agriculture and Society Journal, 22(3), 89-102.
5. Global Farmers’ Movements:
   • Borras, S. M. (2017). Land Grabbing and Global Resistance Movements. Routledge Press.
   • Silva, M. (2020). “Brazil’s MST and the Fight for Land Redistribution.” Latin American Studies Quarterly, 31(2), 41-56.
6. Farm Crisis in the United States:
   • Wright, D. (2019). The Farm Crisis of the 1980s: Causes and Consequences. University of Nebraska Press.
7. Farmers and Trade Policies:
   • Oxfam International. (2020). Unfair Trade Policies and Their Impact on Farmers.
8. Technological and Media Influence on Protests:
   • Sharma, V. (2022). “Digital Activism in Farmers’ Movements: A Global Perspective.” Technology and Society Journal, 48(1), 67-84.
9. Historical Movements:
   • Gill, G. (2018). Punjab Farmers’ Protest of 1906-07: Leadership and Legacy of Sardar Ajit Singh. Punjab Historical Review, 15(4), 91-110.